Does art require thought? Is impulse on its own enough?
Painting: Two Ravens. The spread is from the draft of my upcoming book Creativity As A Way Of Life.
This week I’ve been thinking through the role of journaling in my life, and in Heron Dance’s future. In particular, I’ve been considering the use of more innovative abstract images. I’ve not used images in my personal journal to explore issues of interest and concern in my life or as a spark for my creative process. I’ve focused instead on writing out my thoughts in order to bring clarity to subjects that might benefit from logic. Writing down thoughts, options, concerns adds logic to a process that letting them just flow through my mind lacks.
But this week I’ve spent some time looking at journals by lots of different artists — journals that combine both words and art, though the words are often unintelligible random thoughts. In part I was wondering if this might add something important to my journaling process. Reaching for a thought glimpsed just on the outer edges of understanding is, I’ve found, important in journaling. Is your inner world trying to tell you something?
I was wondering if the creation of journaling pages might, in Heron Dance books and blogs (such as Nurturing), complement my efforts at more abstract art, in combination with excerpts from the journals of novelists, artists, poets, filmmakers and musicians on their creative process. Looking through hundreds of art journals in the last week, I started to ask myself what I was missing. Where’s the logic? Where’s the thought? Many seem like random doodlings lacking skill, thought or a point. Perhaps recording random impulses without thought has value. Maybe a free flow of emotion and impulse is art. Some seem the detritus of mental illness. (I haven’t included those in my examples below. I don’t want to criticize the work of others in Heron Dance. Instead, below I offer examples of journal pages below that I find inspiring or interesting as art).
Notice the similarity of many journal images with a painting pictured below that — one that sold a few years ago at auction for over $100 million. And consider some of Picasso’s paintings. He was out there exploring territory way beyond words, way beyond understanding. But that work, and Basquiat’s below, don’t seem the mere outpouring of emotion, rage. There seems something deeper going on. Maybe I’m wrong. Maybe it is all art, all valid. As I said, there is a striking similarity, at least in terms of abstract shapes, bold colors and stick figures, between many of the artist journal pages I came across in the last week and Basquiat’s work.
I probably won’t start adding images to my own journals. The written process I’ve come to rely on complements my efforts at art so I’ll stick with it. But using images, including abstract images, to accompany excerpts from the journals of creatives, may be a visually interesting way to present to you works and words of creative inspiration. So I’m going to work on that, starting with tomorrow’s post.
In the meantime, below are some examples of artist journals that have got me thinking. These happen to all be from the book 1,000 Artist Journal Pages by Dawn DeVries Sokol.
Below, another Basquiat, Bird On The Money
The painting below looks much like a journal page but is actually a sixteen-foot-wide painting by Basquiat. It sold a few years ago for just over $110 million.
The Deep Silence In Each Of Us
My life is a story of the self-realization of the unconscious. Everything in the unconscious seeks outward manifestation, and the personality too desires to evolve out of its unconscious conditions and experience itself as a whole.
- Carl Jung, from the Prologue to Memories, Dreams.
The Indian Upanishads have a verse about two birds sitting in a tree. One eats fruit and chatters while the other looks silently on. The silent bird is the deep silence in each of us, the quiet place of wisdom.
In my journal, I often turn to that quiet being. I don’t actually envision a bird, or any physical entity, but rather a spirit entity that watches and thinks carefully, without emotion and and then calmly selects the correct course of action.
I ask that entity for guidance. It sometimes responds with a path forward that surprises me. Sometimes that path initially appears unattractive, but I can’t remember a time when I went with it that it didn’t work out, or rejected it and later didn’t regret that rejection.
. . .
If you are not subscribed to either or both Heron Dance Art Studio Substacks, you can do that here:
Nurturing the Song Within, a chronicle of one artist’s efforts to evolve. An exploration of the inner work underlying creative work.
A Pause for Beauty, a celebration of the beauty and mystery of the natural world.
Recent Projects And Random Thoughts
Heron Dance will shortly launch a Kickstarter campaign to fund the printing of the five year quarterly journals described here. There will be a number of premiums associated with this campaign including signed first editions of our latest book, Nurturing the Song Within, art prints and other bonuses. You can keep up-to-date on developments on Kickstarter here.
The new art journal, Nurturing The Song Within, explores the inner work that underlies creative work, and creating a unique life.
If you are not subscribed to either or both Heron Dance Art Studio Substacks, you can do that here:
Nurturing the Song Within, a chronicle of one artist’s efforts to evolve. An exploration of the inner work underlying creative work.
A Pause for Beauty, a celebration of the beauty and mystery of the natural world.